|
The investment houses that ventured so heavily into risky subprime
mortgages and now find themselves holding the bag because millions
of borrowers cant pay those mortgages had best not count
on gaining a sympathetic ear from North Carolina Congressman
Brad Miller. They wont get it.
In fact, Miller thinks the mortgage lending industry has
pretty much reaped what it sowed, and he has little patience
for the investment houses that he asserts knew they were making
bad loans from the start.
Miller, however, does feel for those subprime borrowers who
now find themselves stuck, unable to pay their mortgages,
refinance or sell their homes in a heavily depressed national
housing market.
The Wake County Democrat bidding for a fourth straight term
representing North Carolinas 13th Congressional District,
was sharply critical of the mortgage lending industry in an
interview with The Courier-Times last week while visiting
in Person County during the latest congressional recess.
Miller said he has been involved with mortgage lending issues
and regulation for the past five years in Congress, and during
that time, he charged, mortgage lenders have fought
any kind of legislation to protect consumers at every step
of the way. Theres been no give; theres been no
compromise; there hasnt been much candor about whats
really going on. So I dont have much sympathy for them.
In fact, I dont have any sympathy at all.
Subprime loans typically are high interested loans offered
to individuals who cant qualify for prime loans because
of poor credit. In recent years, investment houses have been
buying up these loans hoping to profit from the greater interest
and fee payments. But then the bottom fell out of the housing
market, many borrowers who couldnt make their payments
found they owed more than the value of their homes, so they
couldnt refinance. Foreclosures ensued.
As for the investment houses, Miller said, They knew
exactly what they were doing they knew exactly what the loans
were that they were buying. They knew that the homeowners
would not be able to pay the loans according to their terms.
In fact, Miller asserted, The loans were intended for
the homeowners to be unable to pay them. They were intended
to catch people in a cycle of having to borrow and then borrow
again to get out of the last [mortgage].
Miller said that between 2005 and 2006, the volume of mortgage
loans rose from eight percent to 28 percent of all mortgage
loans.
According to the Wall Street Journal, he said,
55 percent of the people that had subprime loans qualified
for prime loans for conventional 30-year prime loans.
They simply went to the wrong person [for advice]; they trusted
the wrong person.
Given the complicated nature of mortgages, everyone
has to rely upon advice, Miller observed. And
if you went to the wrong person for advice, you ended up with
a subprime loan, regardless of what your credit was.
According to Miller, about nine in 10 of subprime loans had
adjustable rates that adjusted within two or three years with
the adjustment ranging from seven to 12 percent, resulting
in an increase in the monthly payment of 30 to 50 percent.
Nobody really thought that the
homeowners really
were going to pay the new monthly payment, Miller said.
But [rather that] when the adjustment happened they
would borrow again. They would pay
prepayment penalties
to get out of the old loan, points and fees to get into the
new loan. And in those instances, he said, Instead
of a middle class family building equity in a home, the amount
of their mortgage just chased the value of their home, and
when they got to the point where the amount of the mortgage
was just too much to pay, then they would sell their home.
They could always sell their home as long as they still had
equity in it. [But] What changed was that home values stopped
appreciating.
And all these smart guys on Wall Street, these masters
of the universe, who knew exactly what they were doing, who
knew exactly what these loans were doing to people, got caught
with them, Miller said.
Miller, whose district includes Person County, went on to
say, The estimates are that two million American families
will lose their homes to foreclosure this year and next year.
And it was absolutely predictable. In fact, it was intended.
Everyone involved in mortgage lending knew the hardship that
would result from those loans. They thought the hardship would
all be felt by the middle class families, not by Wall Street,
not by the lending industry. So I dont have much sympathy
for them at all.
Miller said he has sponsored legislation, which has passed
the House Judiciary Committee, that could help families who
meet the financial requirements to file for bankruptcy.
The measure, he said, would permit modification of a home
mortgage in bankruptcy on the same terms that bankruptcy courts
can now modify any other kind of secure debt, by limiting
the amount of debt secured by the asset to the value of the
asset. This could help extend the term of the mortgage at
a manageable interest rate, he indicated.
If you bought more home than you could afford, it doesnt
help you, but if you really can afford the home [but] you
cant afford the mortgage that youve got on it,
itll let you come out of bankruptcy with a mortgage
that you can afford to pay, and it will have the lender come
out of bankruptcy with the mortgage they should have made
in the first place, Miller explained.
He said the Senate is considering similar legislation, which,
he claimed, is vehemently opposed by the financial
services industry.
Regarding the subprime loans, Miller reiterated, The
mortgages that have created the problem should never, ever
have been made. There should never have been a president and
a Congress and regulatory agencies that were so completely
willing to do anything that the financial services industry
wanted them to do, and so completely unconcerned about what
its doing to consumers. Those loans should never, ever
have been made.
Quoting Franklin Roosevelt who said, Heedless greed
is bad morals and also bad economics, Miller said, That
was true 75 years ago, and a new generation of Americans is
learning that its still true.
|